Let’s talk about pricing, because I swear, this is where most eCommerce sellers have their biggest wake-up call. People come into this thinking, “Oh, I’ll just price it lower than everyone else and boom, instant sales.” Yeah, no. That’s not how this works. That’s not how any of this works.
Where You Sell Matters More Than You Think
Before we even get into the psychology of pricing, let’s talk about where you’re selling, because that matters way more than people realize. If you’re throwing your products onto Amazon or eBay and expecting to make real money, you might as well just donate them to charity and call it a day. Those platforms are full of massive companies that can undercut you all day long without even blinking. You’re not just up against other small businesses. You’re up against wholesale suppliers and manufacturers selling directly to customers. And guess what? They can always sell for less than you can.
That’s why the best place for a small eCommerce business is always its own website. You’re not trying to attract bargain hunters looking for the absolute lowest price. You want customers who are searching for exactly what they want and are willing to pay for it. And where do those people go? Google. Way more people search for products on Google than on Amazon, eBay, or Walmart combined. When people are buying on a discretionary basis, meaning they’re picking what they want instead of just hunting for the lowest possible price, they’re not as worried about cost. They care about getting the exact thing they’re looking for. That’s where your business wins.
The Psychology of Charm Pricing
Now, about pricing itself. You ever wonder why so many prices end in .95 or .99? That’s called charm pricing. It’s a psychological trick known as the “left-digit effect,” and it works because the human brain processes numbers weirdly. A single penny or nickel can make a price look significantly lower, even when it’s not. People see $9.99 and register it as nine bucks, even though it’s basically ten. That’s why you see this pricing strategy everywhere.
Here’s where people screw it up. They mix and match their charm pricing, using .95 on some products, .99 on others, maybe even throwing in the occasional .97 for no reason at all. That inconsistency messes with people’s brains. It makes customers feel like something’s off, even if they don’t know why. And the second a customer feels like something isn’t right, your chances of making a sale drop. Pick one, either .95 or .99, and use it consistently across your entire site.
When to Use .00 Pricing
Now, there’s an exception. When you’re running an actual sale, that’s when you use .00. That makes sale prices feel lower, but only when it’s used sparingly. If every price on your site is a “sale” price, customers will see right through it. You know those sites where every single item has the original price crossed out with a “discounted” price underneath? Yeah, customers are onto that scam. They know you’re just inflating prices to make it look like they’re getting a deal. If your entire store is “on sale” all the time, you’re not fooling anyone.
How to Actually Set a Price
So how do you actually set a price? Research. I know, I know, research sounds about as fun as a root canal, but tough luck, you need to do it. Go find at least five or six other businesses selling the exact same product, add up their prices, and divide by six. That gives you the average price of your competition, and that’s where you should be.
Here’s the mistake people make. They think they need to undercut their competitors to get sales. That’s how you end up in a race to the bottom where nobody makes money. Selling is not about having the lowest price. It’s about giving customers what they want through better presentation. When you focus on showing the value of what you’re selling, price becomes secondary, especially for discretionary buyers.
Avoid Pricing Based on Big-Box Retailers
And for the love of everything, don’t do your pricing research on eBay, Amazon, or Walmart unless you’re stuck selling there. Those are bargain-hunting wastelands where profit margins go to die. If you’re selling on your own site, research your pricing on other independent websites, not big-box retailers. Amazon’s prices are often controlled by wholesalers and manufacturers who can afford to sell for next to nothing. If you base your pricing on them, you’ll be out of business before you even get started.
Understanding Common Price Points
There’s one more thing you should know about price points. There’s a site called pricepoints.com that lists commonly used retail price points from zero dollars all the way up to ten thousand. It’s a great tool to see what price points customers are used to seeing, but don’t treat it like gospel. If the average price you calculated from your research is way off from what pricepoints.com suggests, ignore it and go with what makes sense. Once you’ve figured that out, slap either .95 or .99 on the end of all your prices for that left-digit effect, and you’re good to go.
Oh, and if you’ve heard some internet marketer swear that .97 is the magic number, ignore them. That works better for digital products and info sales, not physical products. Stick to what actually works for retail, not whatever gimmick someone’s trying to sell you.
Get Your Pricing Right or Watch Your Business Sink
That’s it. Pricing is not some big mystery, but if you do it wrong, it can absolutely tank your business. Set your prices the right way, use charm pricing consistently, and don’t waste your time fighting bargain hunters on platforms where you can’t win. Sell where customers are looking for what they actually want, and they’ll pay for it.
Here Are Five Things You Can Do Right Now to Fix Your Pricing
First, pick one charm price ending and stick with it.
Either .95 or .99. Not both, not some weird mix of .97 or .93, just one. Go through your entire site and make sure every single price follows the same pattern. If your pricing looks random, customers will notice, and not in a good way.
Second, stop trying to be the cheapest option.
Go find at least five or six businesses selling the same thing you are, average out their prices, and set yours in that range. Customers aren’t picking based on the lowest price. They’re buying from the business that presents the product best. If your product pages look terrible, fixing your price won’t save you.
Third, run a test purchase on your own site.
Pretend you’re a customer, add something to your cart, and go through checkout. If anything about the process makes you hesitate, fix it immediately. If you wouldn’t trust your own store enough to buy from it, neither will anyone else. And no, having a bunch of fake crossed-out “sale” prices isn’t gonna trick anyone.
Fourth, make sure you’re researching prices in the right places.
If you’re selling on your own site, do not base your prices on Amazon, eBay, or Walmart. Those platforms are full of bargain hunters and massive sellers who can afford to undercut everyone else. Find independent stores selling what you sell and use their pricing as a benchmark.
Fifth, check your site’s analytics and see where people are dropping off.
If customers are clicking around but not buying, your pricing or checkout process is probably scaring them away. If you see a bunch of abandoned carts, something’s wrong. Either your pricing looks off, your site’s confusing, or you’re making people jump through too many hoops before they can pay. Fix it, or you’ll keep losing sales.
FREE – get my 
